Controversial Question Should We Charge The Kids Rent

Dated: 06/02/2019

Views: 333

 For a lot of parents, the whole notion of charging a child rent for their lodging in the family’s St. Cloud house seems like an all-but-unthinkable miserly idea. It might seem like an elevation of finance over family—something that crosses a basic societal norm. How in the world could a self-respecting parent place a price tag on providing shelter for their offspring? The issue is real for many St. Cloud families—especially right now, the peak season for high school and college graduations.

Last week, the Wall Street Journal’s Beth DeCarbo provided a thought-provoking commentary on that subject. Its timeliness was framed by her rueful observation that a whole lot of this month’s graduates are “ready for their next big move…back home.”

It could be argued that the statistical support has grown less valid this year because even if “more than one-third of young adults lived at home in 2015,” the current job outlook is considerably brighter than it was (last Friday’s weekly Unemployment Claims were down another thousand). Still, it’s never been uncommon for young adults to need to return to the parental St. Cloud nest while assessing prospects for their first steps into the real world. But what if employment is not a problem? How long is long enough?

The point of the article is that many financial advisers counsel that charging rent to longer-term returning progeny is the preferable arrangement—especially for the returning children themselves. One private wealth adviser points out that the practice teaches kids “to budget, to prepare for life.” The reverse would seem to be logical. Not charging rent to working progeny delays their entry into the real world where landlords and mortgage companies require punctual payment, or else.

A nice sweetener of an idea for soft-hearted St. Cloud parents who would feel terrible about charging rent to the grownup kids came from one mother who regretted not charging “everybody” rent: “I wish we had…and given it back to them after they left!”

Charging rent to other-than-family members is also a possibility for some empty-nesters—although downsizing is more common. For all your St. Cloud real estate prospects, I hope you’ll call me!          

People Gathered Inside House Sitting on Sofa

Providing a superior level of informed, professional real estate services to buyers and sellers throughout Central Minnesota.We have agents specializing in residential, commercial, multifamily, new construction, existing, investment properties, foreclosures/REO, and short sales with offices located in:

Five Office Locations To Serve YOU!

St. Cloud 320-259-4554
Princeton 320-983-3555
Maple Grove763-565-2000
Hutchinson 320-455-9127
Litchfield 320-298-1140

Premier Real Estate specializes MANY areas around Central MN includingSt. Cloud, Waite Park, Rice, Royalton, Sartell, Royalton, Little Falls, Cold Spring, St. Joseph, Elk River, Monticello, Ramsey, Saint Michael, Andover, Ham Lake, Anoka, Champlin, Buffalo, Glencoe, Brownton, Silver Lake, Kandiyohi, Dassel, Minneapolis, Maple Grove, St. Louis Park, Saint Paul, Robbinsdale, Crystal, New Hope, Brooklyn Center and more!

Blog author image

Noel Johnson

Passion for investing in real estate brought me to create Premier Real Estate Services in 2002. Ten years of purchasing & managing several rental properties, while assisting friends & clients with bot....

Want to Advertise on this Site?

Latest Blog Posts

Updating Your Own St Cloud Home With Reclaimed Material

According to Alina Dizik, one of the leading Wall Street Journal’s real estate commentators, agrowing number of luxury homeowners are finding new appreciation for an old idea. In fact, the,

Read More

Author Of Retirement Landmark St Cloud Homeownership

Ever since its introduction in 1965, Americans by the millions have embraced the retirement vehicle known by its IRS handle, the “401(k).”  It hardly matters that few St. Cloud breadwinners

Read More

Uber Controversy Boils As Real Estate Sale Surfaces

This summer’s Uber driver controversy came to a boil over one particularly notable real estate market item. Whether or not St. Cloud residents have ever had occasion to use the web-based taxicab

Read More

Whats Surprising About GenXers And St Cloud Real Estate

By now, just about everyone in St. Cloud looks back on the last decade’s housing bust with a lot less consternation than heretofore—time can do that (as well as the recovery of temporarily lost

Read More