Apr 10 2019 24302 2

Dated: 04/10/2019

Views: 194

 When to Rent vs. Buy

Determining whether to buy or rent your home involves a complex decision-making process. The SmartAsset rent vs. buy calculator helps you see when you’ll reach your break-even point and integrates some of the following questions to help you make an informed choice:

  • How long do you plan on staying in an area?

  • How much flexibility do you enjoy?

  • Are you prepared for the responsibility of homeownership?

Perhaps the most important factor to consider when making this buy or rent decision is how long you plan to stay in your home. If you’ll only be in town a year, renting will almost always be your best choice. In that scenario, if you’re planning to pack up and leave in the short term, you probably don’t want to spend the time and money necessary to buy a house, with a down payment, closing costs, loan charges, appraisal fees and so on.

All told, the upfront costs of finding a house and taking out a mortgage can be in the tens of thousands of dollars (or higher). As a renter, by contrast, you’ll likely just have to pay an application fee, fork over a broker’s fee and make a refundable security deposit of a few months’ rent.

On the other hand, if you plan on staying put for 50 years, renting could be more expensive than buying over that time frame. In the long run, there are significant advantages to homeownership. You’ll own property, which you can later sell, rent out or pass on to family members down the line. Another possible advantage is mortgage interest deduction, a tax benefit that allows you to deduct mortgage interest payments from your taxable income. This requires filing itemized taxes and is only beneficial if the interest deduction totals more than the standard deduction.

Rental payments, by contrast, have no such advantages. While a portion of each mortgage payment goes toward raising your stake in your home by increasing your equity, rental payments go entirely to your landlord and tend to grow over time as rental prices increase. In the long run, the costs of renting can be much higher than buying.


SmartAsset’s interactive buy vs. rent map highlights the places where buying a home is better than renting based on the number of years you plan on staying in your home. The top 10 counties identified below are those places where buying becomes a better financial option than renting in the shortest amount of time.

Find a great interactive map of Minnesota bu county on where it is smart to rent or buy

https://smartasset.com/mortgage/rent-vs-buy#minnesota

Blog author image

George Moore

George has been actively engaged with the housing industry since 1990. His comprehensive expertise is impressive and includes professional titles such as Appraiser, Realtor, Broker, Developer, Builder....

Want to Advertise on this Site?

Latest Blog Posts

2408 Tiffany Court St Cloud 56301

Nothing compares to this custom patio home that has it all! With 10' ceilings in the main area and hand carved ceramic tile plank flooring,

Read More

Good Times Make It Time To Sell Your St Cloud House

 Whenever the U.S. economy is booming, there are naysayers who view it as terrible news. It’s not surprising since economists can disagree about just about anything and point to statistics

Read More

7 Step Progression For Buying St Cloud Homes Under Pressure

 Buying St. Cloud homes takes some degree of organization no matter what. Especially when time is a screaming imperative, it can make or break whether you land a home that’s right—or one

Read More

Which Two Words Are Also Worth 1000 Words

Every now and then we have to shake our heads at how much the electronic transformation has changed daily living in St. Cloud. Electronics have invaded practically everything—from home wifi to

Read More